Six recommendations on how to respond to anti-immigrant movements while protecting the right to protest
By Adrià Cots Fernández, INCLO Civic Space programme manager
Anti-immigrant protests present a real challenge for civil liberties organizations. They often rely, explicitly or implicitly, on racist or xenophobic ideas. They seek to intimidate communities already facing systemic discrimination, and frequently overlap with harassment and violence. Yet, as civil liberties organizations, we have been advocating for decades for an expansive interpretation of the right to protest, one that covers ideas sometimes seen as unpalatable or offensive. We have also argued that isolated acts of violence by some participants should not be used to characterize an entire protest as violent or to justify banning it.
With this tension in mind, INCLO hosted a conversation on how human rights organizations can respond to anti-immigrant protests flaring up in the Global North and Global South, as recently seen in Northern Ireland, South Africa, and Spain. Here are some takeaways from this discussion. There are no one-size-fits-all answers, and none of the recommendations below are prescriptive. Every approach involves trade-offs that each organization must weigh in its own context.
1. Hold a consistent line on the limits of protest. The right to protest covers all viewpoints, including ones we strongly disagree with. But this protection has limits. It does not extend to protesters who incite discrimination or promote violence. In other words, the focus should be on how protesters act, not what they believe in. Applying this principle consistently can stop the far right from appropriating the right to protest, as it demonstrates that we support it for everyone, with no double standards and no discrimination.
2. Expanding police powers is not the solution. Law enforcement has a long record of rights violations against oppressed groups, and migrants are among its targets, frequently through racial profiling. Furthermore, the police have repeatedly failed to protect migrant populations from harassment and violence by the far-right, and their presence in protests may contribute to exacerbating tensions. INCLO’s 2024 report ‘In Our Hands’ (now a Spanish-language podcast) provides several powerful examples of how community-led initiatives can replace police interventions and provide more durable security.
3. Demand equal protection and access to services. Most countries have laws that ban incitement to hatred and violence, and ordinary criminal law already sanctions physical violence and threats. However, authorities often fail to investigate effectively when migrants are the target of such actions. Similarly, on many occasions authorities fail to provide survivors with appropriate support, such as housing and physical and mental health care, either because of ingrained stigma and discrimination against migrants, or because people with insecure migrant status are legally excluded from the safety net. Ensuring equality in these protections will provide more safety to migrant communities than restrictions on protests.
4. Build your own narrative around values, not facts. Participants shared that fact-based arguments, fact-checking, and myth-busting are often ineffective at countering anti-immigrant messaging. Instead, communication based on shared community, democratic values, and humour can work. Do not engage with hate content and misinformation, and focus on a vision for what you want your community to look like. Organizations such as Hope and Courage in Ireland, CounterX in South Africa, or Por Causa in Spain and Chile provide inspiration for different approaches to this task.
5. Protect the civic space of migrant organizations and first responders. When xenophobic tensions rise, migrant rights organizations and first responders often face harassment, and even violence. This disrupts essential services for people most at risk and has a deep chilling effect. Civil liberties organizations should prioritize advocating for a safe, enabling environment for organizations led by and working with migrants, so they face no legal barriers, are protected from attacks, and receive adequate funding and resources.
6. Invest in long-term solidarity with the migrant rights movement. Solidarity between migrant populations and the wider community runs deep. Anti-ICE activism shows how powerful such alliances can be in protecting individuals from migration raids, shifting political discourse, and eventually revising policies; in certain jurisdictions, it may have significantly contributed to recent electoral results in the United States. Human rights organizations should invest in fostering national and international coalitions of migrant rights groups to achieve long-term change.
This panel discussion was held on November 5, 2026, as part of our Time-out series, which brings together INCLO members and close allies to discuss challenging questions on how we practice human rights. Special thanks to Lucía Galoppo of the Centro de Estudios Legales y Sociales (CELS, Argentina), who facilitated the discussion, and to Sherylle Dass of the Legal Resources Centre (LRC, South Africa) and Alianza Américas’ (USA) Helena Orea for their opening interventions.
Photo: Anti-immigration protest in Aberdeen, Scotland, on 6 September 2025 by Lucas Kendall – Own work, CC BY-SA 4.0, https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Special:Redirect/page/174834236















